- The Verb Kārâ (כָּרָה): The Masoretes pointed
כריתas kāritā—a Qal perfect 2nd-person masculine singular verb meaning "you have dug" or "hollowed out". In Biblical Hebrew, kārâ is strictly used for digging pits, wells, or graves (e.g., Gen. 26:25, Ps. 7:15). Applying "digging" to "ears" (’oznayim) is a hapax legomenon in the Hebrew Bible. - Distinction from the Ear-Boring Ritual: Commentators often try to defend the MT by linking it to the Exodus 21:6 slave ritual ("boring the ear"). However, the Torah uses an entirely different verb for piercing an ear (rāṣa‘ / רָצַע), not kārâ.
- Alternative Vocalization of the Root: Without the Tiberian vowel points,
כריתcan be vocalized from a cognate sense meaning "to prepare, fashion, or acquire" (cf. Hosea 3:2, where kārâ means to purchase/provide, or Ugaritic kr). The LXX translator who rendered this as katērtisō ("you have prepared/fitted") likely understood a vocalization reflecting "fashioned/prepared" rather than "dug."
- Re-segmentation Hypothesis: The letters $א-ז-נ-י-ם$ (’znym) in early palaeo-Hebrew script look remarkably similar to $א-ז\ \ ג-ו-י-ה$ (’āz gəviyyâ—"then a body") or $א-ז\ \ ג-ו$ (’āz gev—"then a body").
- Under this reconstruction, a scribe or later vocalizer misread the
$ג$ (gimel) and $ו$ (vav) as a $נ$ (nun) and $י$ (yod), fusing "then a body" (’āz gəviyyâ) into "ears" (’oznayim). When the Masoretes pointed the text centuries later, they vocalized the corrupt consonantal string into the dual noun ’oznayim ("ears").
In summary, the Masoretic vocalization forces an otherwise unknown idiom ("digging ears"), whereas alternative vocalizations or slight consonantal re-segmentations better align with the ancient translation tradition (sōma / "body") cited authoritatively in Hebrews 10:5.